Students as Questioners 5: Questions in the Disciplines

manyquestionsOne of the three keys I’ve identified for supporting creativity in the classroom is teaching the creative methodologies of the disciplines you are teaching. “Teaching the creative methodologies” is a fancy phrase for the idea that, whatever subject you are teaching, you teach not just the “what” of the subject but the “how” as well. It means you ask yourself and your students, “How did the ideas we are studying come to be?”

Perhaps the distinction is most easily seen in history. There is a lot of content to be taught in history. When I was young, I was taught history as a series of facts to be memorized: When did WWII start? Who said, “We have nothing to fear but fear itself?” Now I understand that good teaching of history emphasizes the whys, relationships, and varied perspectives that help us make sense of people’s actions in differing times and places. But all of that is still the “what” of history. It doesn’t answer the questions, “How do I know what happened? How do I know why?” To begin thinking about those questions, we need to understand a bit about what historians do and how they do it. That is the “how” of history.

pilgrimsWhen I’ve started talking to students (young and old) about this question, I’ve often asked, “What did the pilgrims wear?” The answer is quick in coming, “Men wore tall hats, dark clothes, and shoes with big buckles. Women wore dresses bonnets.” Then I ask, “How do you know?”

The first answer is either, “My teacher told me,” or “I read it in a book.”

“How did your teacher know?” “How did the person who wrote the book know? Do you think the author had ever seen a pilgrim?”

With young children, this generally leads to puzzled faces. How did the person who wrote the book know? They probably read another book. But how did that author know? After some time and conversation, we come around to the idea that just like TV detectives, people who study history have to look for evidence of what has happened. They ask questions and look for clues. So what kinds of clues give us hints about what the pilgrims wore? We don’t have photographs, but we do have paintings.

That idea can lead to an interesting insight when I ask, “Do you think all pilgrims had their pictures painted?” “Do you think the people who had their pictures painted were more likely rich or poor?” “When they had their pictures painted, would they likely be wearing their everyday clothes or their best clothes?” “What if a pilgrim was plowing a field or cooking dinner. Would that people be wearing the same clothes as in the painting?”

We don’t know. Exactly! Now we have a question. What did pilgrims wear in their everyday life? And how would historians figure that out? That is the beginning of understanding the “How” of history.

Helping students ask questions within disciplines does more than support curiosity and creativity. It helps students understand that knowledge doesn’t emerge fully formed from a textbook, but is developed over time as people ask questions and (as Deborah Meier suggests) ask “What’s the evidence?”

For the next few weeks I’ll consider the types of questioning that might be taught across disciplines. Since I’m not an expert in all disciplines, I’ll be grateful for your help along the way. Perhaps now is a good time to begin thinking, whatever subject you teach, how did the knowledge in that subject come to be? What questions do creative people in that field explore? And how can we share those with the students we teach?

PS If you’d like to see more accurate information on what the pilgrims wore, you might enjoy this link. It still doesn’t share the evidence for the conclusions, but it is a start.

If you’d rather go straight to a particular discipline, here are the links.

Students as Questioners in Math

Students as Questioners in Science

Students as Questioners in History

Students as Questioners in Writing.

3 thoughts on “Students as Questioners 5: Questions in the Disciplines

  1. Pingback: People and Cultures: Preparing Junior Ethnographers | creativiteach

  2. Pingback: Creativity and Talent Development: The Middle Years | creativiteach

  3. Pingback: Creativity and Curriculum: What Do We Teach? | creativiteach

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s