Students as Questioners 6: What Do Historians Ask?

magnifyingglassOne key way to encourage student questioning is to think about the questions that creative professionals in a discipline might ask. Every field moves forward when individuals ask questions. Helping students understand the questions in a field helps them envision how the creative processes of the discipline move forward.

So, what about history? As a student, I spent years thinking of history as a seemingly unending series of facts to be memorized. If I thought about questions about history, I envisioned multiple choice! But there can be a better way. History is a series of glorious mysteries starting with the clues—primary sources. Examining primary sources leads to the questions, and occasionally even the answers, of history.

Of course your first task, whatever grade level you are teaching, is to locate appropriate primary sources. In these days of electronic resources, almost anything is possible. You can find online collections of cookbooks, music, and virtually anything else you can envision. The Library of Congress has abundant resources for American History, and a bit of exploration will help you find reproductions of artifacts around the world. These are the clues. Even young children know what investigators do with clues—they examine them carefully and ask questions.

The most basic of historical research questions are these:

What do you observe?

What do you hypothesize (or infer)?

What do you wonder?

Helping students understand the difference between observation and inference is basic to history, and to many other disciplines as well. For example, take a look at this image of Colonial Boston.

Boston

What do you see? What might you infer about life in the colony? You can observe images of buildings, men with hand tools, a ship, and carriages being pulled by horses. You might infer that land transportation was done mainly by horse, but that would be an inference. You’d need more investigation to confirm that hypothesis. And, of course, you can also start thinking about what the picture makes you wonder. For example, what were those big buildings made of? You might hunt for other pictures of Colonial Boston to investigate. Would this picture help?

Boston2

Of course, the three basic questions are just a start. As students become more skilled questioners they can begin to think about the people who created the artifacts—their purposes and perspectives. These could lead to some of the questions suggested by Deborah Meier:

What’s the evidence?

Could there be another point of view (or was this created to promote a particular view?)

Are there patterns? Are the artifacts consistent?

Clearly, considering all the strategies of historical research is a bigger task than we can manage here, but a few basic questions are a way to start. If students can think of history as detective work, it can come to life in new creative ways. Do you have a good strategy for bringing historical questions to life? We’d love to hear it.

One thought on “Students as Questioners 6: What Do Historians Ask?

  1. Pingback: Students as Questioners 5: Questions in the Disciplines | creativiteach

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s